Band Saw Vs Scroll Saw ( What is the difference? )

Scroll saws and band saws are both woodworking tools used to cut curves and shapes in wood. They each have their own unique benefits and drawbacks, so which one is right for you? In this article, we’ll take a look at the pros and cons of each tool so you can decide which is best for your needs.

What is the difference between Band Saw and Scroll Saw?

Scroll Saw

A scroll saw is a small, tabletop saw with a narrow blade and a small work table. The tool can be powered by an electric motor, or it can run on its own, which enables portable operation. Scroll saws are used to cut intricate curves and patterns into wood.

Pros:   

  • Portable, affordable power options (electricity or battery), able to perform intricate cuts

Cons:   

  • Small blade, difficult to make straight cuts in long pieces of wood

Band Saw

With a band saw, the cutting element is a thin steel band with sharp teeth. The blade moves quickly and can be used to make both curved and straight cuts. The size of a band saw’s blade is not limited, so this tool is able to use larger blades than a scroll saw.

Pros: 

  • Band saws are able to cut through thick pieces of wood more easily than scroll saws, which makes them ideal for projects involving solid lumber. 
  • The size of the blade also allows band saw users to make very straight cuts. They are also more cost-effective for the average woodworker.

Cons: 

  • A band saw is difficult to transport and set up, and it can be noisy when in use.

Band Saw vs Scroll Saw – Which One Is Right For You?

Both tools offer distinct advantages over the other, but neither one is best suited for every single woodworking task. Scroll saws are a great choice if you only need to make a few cuts in sheet goods, but a band saw would be better for large, solid projects. If you want to cut lots of curves and tight patterns, the scroll saw will do the job much more quickly than a band saw. Keep in mind that both tools have portable options, although they are not as portable as a hand saw, for instance. If you want the most versatility from your woodworking tools, then adding both of these machines to your workshop would be ideal.

How do band saws and scroll saws work?

Both saws use a thin blade that is moved back and forth by an electric or hand-powered motor. The blade of the scroll saw is much thinner than the band saw, which means smaller cuts can be made with this tool. Scroll saw blades move in a continuous circular motion, while band saw blades move up and down (flat). Band saws have a stiff flat table on which the wood is placed, whereas scroll saws have a much lower table where more of the blade can be seen.

Scroll saw blades move in a continuous circular motion, while band saw blades move up and down (flat). Band saws have a stiff flat table on which the wood is placed, whereas scroll saws have a much lower table where more of the blade can be seen.

If you already own a scroll saw and are looking to purchase your first band saw, there are some things to consider. Scroll saw blades are typically thinner than band saw blades, which means that they can’t cut through as thick of materials. But on the other hand, band saws cut much wider curves and make more precise cuts. 

This means that you can’t always use a bandsaw to cut a piece of wood down to a smaller size than would be possible with a scroll saw. Another difference is that band saws have a stiff flat table on which the wood is placed, whereas scroll saws have a much lower table where more of the blade can be seen. Scroll saws are generally cheaper than comparably sized band saws. 

The biggest difference between the two tools is that scroll saw blades move in a continuous circular motion, while band saw blades move up and down (flat). Bandsaws have less vibration due to this setup because there is no continuous motion of the blade.

What are the benefits of using a band saw vs a scroll saw?

While both tools have their individual strengths and weaknesses, a band saw is usually considered to be more versatile than a scroll saw. They can often cut wider curves and thicker pieces of wood. Bandsaws are actually capable of being used for relatively narrow cuts as well, but they’re much better suited to making large straight cuts that would be impossible with a scroll saw. 

Bandsaws are also quieter than scroll saws, and they’re less likely to break your fingers if you accidentally get in the way of the blade! There is less vibration due to the additional stability over a scroll saw blade, which allows for faster cutting. In addition, band saws can cut through much larger materials than scroll saws.

If you already own a scroll saw and are looking to purchase your first band saw, there are some things to consider. Scroll saw blades are typically thinner than a band saw blades, which means that they can’t cut through as thick of materials. But on the other hand, band saws cut much wider curves and make more precise cuts. This means that you can’t always use a bandsaw to cut a piece of wood down to a smaller size than would be possible with a scroll saw. 

Another difference is that band saws have a stiff flat table on which the wood is placed, whereas scroll saws have a much lower table where more of the blade can be seen. Scroll saws are generally cheaper than comparably sized band saws. The biggest difference between the two tools is that scroll saw blades move in a continuous circular motion, while band saw blades move up and down (flat). Bandsaws have less vibration due to this setup because there is no continuous motion of the blade.

Which tool is better for your needs – the band saw or the scroll saw?

While both tools have their individual strengths and weaknesses, a band saw is usually considered to be more versatile than a scroll saw. They can often cut wider curves and thicker pieces of wood. Bandsaws are actually capable of being used for relatively narrow cuts as well, but they’re much better suited to making large straight cuts that would be impossible with a scroll saw. Bandsaws are also quieter than scroll saws, and they’re less likely to break your fingers if you accidentally get in the way of the blade!

There is less vibration due to the additional stability over a scroll saw blade, which allows for faster cutting. In addition, band saws can cut through much larger materials than scroll saws.

Conclusion:

A band saw is a great choice for larger, bulkier pieces of wood that need to be cut. If you don’t have a lot of experience with woodworking or are working on a smaller project, a scroll saw is the better option. Both tools have their own advantages and disadvantages, so it’s important to consider what you will be using the tool for before making your purchase!