Carcass Saw vs Tenon Saw

There are many types of saws on the market, and it can be daunting trying to determine which is the best one for the job at hand.

In this post, we’ll compare two popular saws: the carcass saw and the tenon saw. We’ll look at the pros and cons of each to help you decide which is right for you. So, let’s get started!

Carcass Saw vs Tenon Saw – Which is Better?

When it comes to carpentry saws, the two main types are the carcass saw and the tenon saw. Both have their own unique strengths and benefits, but which one is right for you?

We’ll take a closer look at both types of saws and help you decide which one is best for your needs. Stay tuned!

Carcass Saw:

The carcass saw has a broad and short blade, and it’s typically used to make cuts in the wood which have straight lines. It comes with a wooden handle, and it offers just the right amount of grip for this kind of job. The saw can be pulled or pushed to cut through wood.


This type is one of the most versatile and common types around today.

You can use it on almost any material; you aren’t limited in what you’re cutting like some circular saws are (the size of their base usually determines what they can cut).

They provide great control over the depth and angles you need when cutting.


The blades can fray, but this can be prevented by regularly filing down the blades. Also, they tend to produce a lot of waste when cutting larger pieces of hardwood.

Tenon Saw:

The tenon saw has a short and narrow blade with sharp teeth on the end. It’s commonly used for woodworking purposes such as making crosscuts and more detailed cuts in drywall.

The handle provides great control over the saw; it allows you to cut very precisely thanks to its small size and weight (it weighs around 7 pounds).


Due to its size and weight, this type of saw is very intuitive and easy to use once you’ve had some practice with it.

It’s extremely versatile; it provides good control over all angles while cutting, and it’s a popular choice for cutting thin material.


This saw cannot be used to cut through thick pieces of material; it can only be used with thinner wood.

It also does not provide good control over the depth of the cuts you make. In addition, the finer teeth on this saw mean that it takes longer to do any job than a regular saw would.

You also have less control when push-pulling the blade so you need more room around your workbench for protection from misshapen cuts!


What are the key features to look for when purchasing either type of saw? 

When choosing between either type of saw, one key determining factor is the quality of the blade. Make sure that it’s made out of high-quality steel to ensure that it will keep its sharpness for longer.

Additionally, make sure that there are enough teeth on the blade; more teeth mean a finer cut and less fraying while cutting hardwood.

What should I look for when trying to purchase either type of saw? 

When you’re first looking at either type of saw, first consider what it is that you’ll be using the saw for. This will help determine whether or not the size and weight are beneficial to your needs.

Next, think about whether you need a push or pull action, and then check the depth of cut you might need.

What is a good saw to use for both softwood and hardwood?

Due to its size and weight, the tenon saw can be used with both materials. However, it’s best used on harder woods where it’ll provide a cleaner cut while giving you more control over the shape and depth of the cut.

What is a good saw to use for cutting drywall?

The tenon saw is best used for cutting drywall because it gives you more control over what shape and size cut you’re making, and it will produce less damage than a regular saw would. It also weighs less than the carcass saw so you have more control over the angles.

Which saw do you prefer and why?

I prefer the tenon saw for two reasons.

The first reason is that I like to make smaller cuts and this saw provides good control over how fine the cut will be.

The second reason is that it’s great for using on drywall; I feel more comfortable working with hardwood rather than drywall, but if you’re looking to do anything with drywall, I recommend this saw.


While both types of saws have their pros and cons, if you’re looking for a versatile type then a carcass saw is probably best suited to your needs. If you’d rather invest in a saw that’s easier to control when it comes to the depth and angles of the cuts, then you should consider getting a tenon saw.